The Credit Impact of a Credit Card’s Life Cycle

8 Comments
  1. AT

    Hi Ricky,

    I have one or two no annual fee cards that I’ve had for a very long time, however I never use them. Is it better for my credit score to close them because of the low utilization, or keep the open because of the AAoA? Thank you!

  2. Thomy4

    Is your credit rating affected by not using the card, once you’ve received the bonus points and paid it off?

  3. Vishesh Parekh

    Is there a significant difference in scoring algorithms between TU & EQ? If not, why there is a huge difference in scores, whereas there is no difference in utilization, history, or paying on time? I have TU score of 794 and at the same time EQ score of 684 !! Thats a difference of almost 110 points. Same for P2, there is a difference of almost 125 points. I dont understand this. And never show any significant improvements in EQ score over the time. TU score drops & moves up quite fast. Can you chime on this? Completely out of mind.

    1. Ricky YVR

      They each have their own proprietary algorithms, placing different weights on different factors. In addition, different credit issuers place inquiries to different bureaus (for example, Amex pulls from TransUnion, whereas TD pulls from Equifax, etc.) so that can also explain part of it.

      I wouldn’t overthink this difference too much, as long as you’re taking good care of the factors that are within your control (payment history and utilization).

  4. Jeff H TOR

    So, having a high Credit limit is actually a good thing? How does having a high credit limit (and not utilizing it) affect my ability to get more cards (more bonuses). Was recently approved for two high end cards; both amex. Business PLatinum card and then the (p) Bonvoy amex (21,000 limit upon instant approval)

    1. Ricky YVR

      Having a high credit limit makes it easy to keep your utilization at a reasonable level. However, having too high a credit limit, while it doesn’t affect your credit score, can cause some issuers to think that you’re "overextended" (i.e., you have too much credit available to you at the moment); some people choose to voluntarily lower their highest credit limits for this reason. This would fall into the category of individual factors that each issuer looks at that I mentioned at the end of the article.

  5. James

    Saw a whopping 80+ point drop in Equifax after getting a personal AMEX platinum. It’s starting to slowly recover. Over the same period of time, got a 40 point increase in TransUnion. No balances, no cancellations, no other applications, nothing unusual in utilization… I know it’s all just math, but sometimes I really don’t understand it!

  6. Jenny

    Just a suggestion, but could you please make your RSS button more visible? It was a nightmare to find and I had to go through SquareSpace documentation to subscribe to your RSS feed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have an Account? Click here to Login